BRA Under Scrutiny: Where Does Informing End and Influencing Begin?
A public disagreement has emerged over the Blouberg Residents Association’s role in communicating local concerns and encouraging residents to report alleged planning violations. We examine questions raised about the BRA’s impartiality, its approach to soliciting complaints, and where the line should be drawn between keeping residents informed and influencing public opinion.

The following message was posted by the BRA Chairman, Jan Derksen, on the Blouberg Village Matters social media page. It is the latest episode of a long running spat between the BRA, certain residents, the owners of On the Rocks and Onse Huise restaurants and Mr Jerry Finlay, owner of The Lighthouse coffee shop, no 47 Stadler Road.
“The BRA has been inundated with residents objecting to the new commercial food and beverage operations that have commenced trading at 52 Stadler Road, apparently operated by, or with the authority of, Mr Jerry Finley and/or One Vision Investments 2 (Pty) Ltd, understood to be the property owner.
“The reported activities include All in the Kitchen selling bakery and food items from the garage, and a mobile coffee operation in the driveway or forecourt. Serving tables and customer seating have also been placed at the premises. A mobile burger unit has reportedly been positioned outside, with trading intended to commence soon. Illegal business signage has also been placed at the property.
“*We (presumably the BRA) understand that the property has no approval authorising these commercial operations.* Please note the BRA has reported it to the authorities. As individuals that object please log a C3 on the City portal. https://eservices1.capetown.gov.za/coct/wapl/zsreq_app/index.html#/create
I, the Editor, took exception to this posting and responded:
Good morning Jan
I received your diatribe on Thursday regarding business activities in Stadler Road. While not a supporter of Mr Finlay I am committed to good governance and fair play. I am the editor and instigator of Blouberg Life, and a journalist of many years standing.
My concern with your diatribe is that it is not objective - you state that the BRA has been inundated with complaints but don’t say how many or what percentage of members have complained. Through other media via the BRA there have been vitriolic messages against Mr Finlay which could be classified as hate speech. Also that media publishes such hate speech from anonymous supporters. Any editor worth his/her salt and reputation would instantly delete such comments, hiding their identity is an act of cowardice and incitement.
Further my understanding was that the BRA was a responsive organisation not one that solicits members to complete C3’s to the council. I’d be happy to discuss these issues by way of a response to intended content in the next issue of Blouberg Life.
Rgds
Robin Hayes
The conversation is ongoing.
